How to Know When a Contractor Doesn’t Want Your Job

When a contractor comes to your home to give you an estimate, most homeowners are thinking about one thing: Do I want to hire this contractor?

Are they knowledgeable? Do they seem trustworthy? Are they properly insured? Is their price reasonable? Do I feel comfortable having them work on my property?

Those are all questions you should be asking.

But there’s another side to the estimate that homeowners don’t always think about:

The contractor is deciding whether they want the job, too.

After more than 30 years in the contracting and service industry, I can tell you that good contractors don’t want every project that comes their way.

Sometimes the project isn’t right for their company. Sometimes the timing doesn’t work. Sometimes the property makes the work far more difficult than it needs to be. And sometimes the contractor decides that the customer may not be someone they want to work with.

And they don’t always come right out and tell you.

How Can You Tell?

The estimate comes back unusually high.

There are plenty of legitimate reasons one contractor may be considerably more expensive than another, so don’t automatically assume a high estimate means they don’t want your job.

But the “I really don’t want this job” price absolutely exists.

Sometimes a contractor looks at the difficulty, risk, inconvenience, or potential problems involved and decides they’ll take the project—but only if there’s enough money in it to make everything that comes with it worthwhile.

They don’t seem particularly interested in getting the job.

They’re polite. They answer your questions. They may even send you an estimate.

But there’s not much enthusiasm, follow-up, or effort to move the project forward.

Sometimes they’ve simply decided the project isn’t a great fit.

The estimate takes forever—or never comes.

Contractors get busy. Estimates get delayed. That alone doesn’t mean someone doesn’t want your project.

But contractors also tend to prioritize the jobs they’re most interested in.

Sometimes an estimate keeps finding its way to the bottom of the pile for a reason.

They’re booked much further out than you expected.

They may genuinely be booked. Good contractors often are.

But occasionally, “We probably can’t get to this for six months” is a polite way of letting a homeowner continue looking.

They recommend somebody else.

This isn’t necessarily a bad sign at all.

In fact, a contractor who realizes another company is better equipped or better suited for your particular project and tells you so may be doing exactly what a good contractor should do.

Why Would a Contractor Turn Down Work?

There are probably more reasons than most homeowners realize.

Your project may be too small—or too large—for their operation.

Imagine a tree company that leaves the yard every morning with multiple trucks, a large chipper, specialized equipment, and a full crew. Their operation may be designed primarily around larger tree removals.

They might be perfectly capable of trimming a few branches from one tree. But sending that entire operation to a small trimming project may simply not make financial sense.

A smaller company may actually be a much better fit.

The opposite is also true. A smaller contractor may look at a large, complicated project and recognize that another company is better equipped to handle it.

It’s not the kind of work their company is set up to do.

Being capable of doing something doesn’t necessarily mean a contractor wants to do it.

A tree company that primarily performs removals may not be interested in filling its schedule with small pruning jobs. Another company may specialize in pruning and tree preservation and love exactly that kind of work.

Good businesses eventually learn what they’re good at, what they’re efficient at, and what kinds of projects make the most sense for their operation.

Access can completely change a project.

A job can look fairly straightforward until the contractor sees the property.

Maybe a smaller tree company realizes the removal would be considerably easier with a crane. They could hire a crane company and coordinate everything themselves, but they may simply decide they don’t want the additional logistics, expense, or risk.

The same thing happens with landscaping, excavation, fencing, and many other outdoor projects.

Sometimes the work isn’t the problem.

Getting to the work is.

The property itself can make the job unnecessarily difficult.

Contractors notice what’s around the work area.

A backyard filled with trampolines, bicycles, toys, patio furniture, clotheslines, equipment, and other obstacles can turn a relatively straightforward project into a headache.

Nobody expects your property to be perfect. But if you’ve scheduled an estimate, making the work area reasonably accessible shows consideration.

And yes, that includes picking up after your dog.

It may seem insignificant, but contractors are already looking ahead and thinking:

What is it going to be like bringing my crew and equipment onto this property?

Sometimes It Isn’t the Project. It’s the Customer.

This is the part contractors don’t always say out loud.

Experienced contractors learn to recognize relationships that may become problematic before a contract is ever signed.

If the first conversation is already argumentative, aggressive, disrespectful, or confrontational, a contractor may decide the job simply isn’t worth it.

If every conversation revolves around beating down the price, that can be another warning sign.

If the project changes five times while they’re trying to prepare the estimate, they may wonder how many times it’s going to change once the work begins.

And here’s a big one:

If you spend the entire estimate explaining how every other contractor you’ve ever hired was dishonest, incompetent, overpriced, or terrible, eventually the contractor standing in your yard may start wondering:

“Am I going to be the next one?”

That doesn’t mean homeowners shouldn’t ask questions.

You should.

It doesn’t mean you shouldn’t negotiate, question a price, point out concerns, or expect a contractor to earn your business.

You should do those things, too.

There’s simply a difference between being an informed customer and creating an adversarial relationship before the project has even begun.

Contractors Don’t Have to Take Every Job

This is something that occasionally surprises people.

There can be an assumption that because a contractor is in business and you’re willing to pay them, they’re somehow obligated to take your project.

They’re not.

I’ve had people become genuinely upset because we didn’t want to take on their work, almost as though being in business meant we were required to accept every customer who called.

That’s simply not how it works.

A homeowner has every right to meet three contractors and decide:

“I don’t want to hire any of them.”

A contractor has that same choice.

They have to consider their schedule, crews, equipment, profitability, risk, the type of work they specialize in, and whether they believe the working relationship is going to be a good one.

Sometimes turning down a project isn’t personal.

It’s simply a good business decision.

Respect Goes Both Ways

Homeowners should expect contractors to respect their home, their time, and their money.

Contractors should communicate professionally, show up when they say they will, answer reasonable questions, and treat someone’s property with care.

But that respect goes both ways.

If you’ve scheduled an estimate, make the area reasonably accessible. Secure pets if necessary. Move obvious obstacles when you can. Be prepared to explain what you’re trying to accomplish. And treat the person who came to look at your project with the same respect you expect from them.

Because there’s something worth remembering the next time you’re getting an estimate:

You’re deciding whether you want to hire the contractor.

They’re deciding whether they want to work for you.

And that’s actually a good thing.

The best projects aren’t created simply by finding a good contractor.

They happen when the homeowner, the contractor, and the project are a good fit for each other.

Tree413Your Most Trusted Advisor